New Study Examines State Standards Reform and Student Achievement

July 27, 2012
by Doug Gavel

Clarifying what students should be learning does not necessarily translate into higher achievement in the classroom. That is the finding in a new research study conducted by Harvard Kennedy School Assistant Professor Joshua Goodman.
All states have documents describing what students should be learning in various academic subjects at various ages. Goodman sought to determine whether increasing the quality of those written standards leads to improved student achievement. The study comes at a time when many leaders are intent on improving educational outcomes through enhanced student preparation, testing and measurement.
"Given the immense amount of time and money being spent on such efforts, it is surprising how little evidence policymakers and educators have on the impact of such standards on student achievement," Goodman writes. "Little is known...about how the quality of written standards translates into improvements in curriculum, pedagogy and student achievement."
Goodman examined data on state-level student achievement between 1994-2011, correlating achievement shifts with corresponding shifts in the quality of each state's written standards. He concluded that changes in standards have little impact on overall student achievement.
"Improved math standards do, however, raise the math achievement of 8th graders, particularly for low-scoring students," he writes. "Given the known weaknesses of U.S. middle schools, this result suggests that standards may be beneficial in settings where achievement would otherwise be low."
Joshua S. Goodman, Assistant Professor of Public Policy at Harvard Kennedy School, teaches empirical methods and the economics of education. His research interests include labor and public economics, with a particular focus on education policy. He has explored whether merit scholarships impact the college enrollment decisions of high school graduates, the extent to which low college enrollment rates of low income students are due to financial constraints or low academic skill, and the labor market impact of forcing high school students to take more math courses.

photograph of Joshua Goodman

Joshua Goodman, Assistant Professor of Public Policy

"Given the immense amount of time and money being spent on such efforts, it is surprising how little evidence policymakers and educators have on the impact of such standards on student achievement," Goodman writes.

 


John F. Kennedy School of Government 79 John F. Kennedy Street
Cambridge, MA 02138
617-495-1100 Get Directions Visit Contact Page