Holdren Outlines Options to Address Global Warming Challenge

November 7, 2007
Elizabeth Gehrman

"Global warming is a misnomer," said John P. Holdren, speaking Tuesday night (Nov. 6) at the John F. Kennedy Jr. Forum at the Kennedy School. "It implies something gradual, uniform, and benign. What we’re experiencing is none of these."

Holdren, the Teresa and John Heinz Professor of Environmental Policy at the Kennedy School and director of the program in science, technology, and public policy at the Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs, went on to outline the current and likely future effects of global warming, as well as its anthropogenic — or man-made — nature.

"The disruption and its impacts have grown ore widely than anyone ever expected a few years ago," Holdren contended. To fix the problem, he said, society has only three options: mitigation, adaptation, and suffering. "We’re already doing some of each, and will do more of all three."

Climate change affects the availability of water, agricultural production, the formation and dispersion of air pollutants, the geography of disease, natural disasters, and much more. For those who may still be skeptical that global warming is happening, or that it is caused by human intervention, Holdren said, "There is good reason to put on the brakes before we go over the cliff. If you’re driving over a cliff, you’re not going to listen to people who say, ‘Listen, it’s foggy and you don’t know where the cliff is.’"

Holdren had plenty of evidence to rebut skepticism, discussing studies that showed the steady rise in annual mean temperatures since 1880, when records were first kept; the current geographic distribution of heating, which indicates that it’s concentrated in the far north of the globe; and changes in monsoon patterns, evaporation, precipitation, and sea level. Permafrost is thawing, he pointed out; arctic summer sea ice is disappearing; surface melting on Greenland is expanding; and sea level is rising.

"These changes," Holdren said, "are already causing harm." Major flooding is up virtually everywhere in the world, he said. Wildfires are also increasing — in the United States, fourfold in the past 30 years — which adds to the carbon dioxide in the atmosphere, creating what Holdren called a vicious circle. The power of tropical storms has increased almost in lockstep with the increased temperature of the sea surface, which is also acidifying the oceans, threatening coral reefs and any creature that makes its shell out of calcium carbonate. The World Health Organization estimates that, by 2000, climate change was already causing 150,000 premature deaths a year, and, Holdren said, "bigger disruption is coming."

Holdren told the Forum audience that if we don’t take sufficient steps quickly to both mitigate the effects of and adapt to the impacts of climate change, the world will suffer.

"There is no panacea," Holdren said. "We need a portfolio of choices." The next most important steps, he added, are to accelerate "win-win" mitigation and adaptation measures, integrating them with current development plans; to put a price on greenhouse gas emissions so the marketplace can work to find the cheapest reductions; to expand international cooperation; and to sharply increase investments in energy-technology research and development.

Holdren’s most important message, perhaps, was that the United States must spearhead this effort, going from being a "laggard in climate policy to being a leader." Once that happens, he said, the rest of the world will follow suit.

To watch a video of the event, visit the John F. Kennedy Jr. Forum archive: http://iopforum.harvard.edu:8080/ramgen/fr20071106climate.rm?start=0:00:06.0

Photo: Rose Lincoln, Harvard News Office

John Holdren image

John Holdren, Teresa and John Heinz Professor of Environmental Policy

John F. Kennedy School of Government 79 John F. Kennedy Street
Cambridge, MA 02138
617-495-1100 Get Directions Visit Contact Page